Unlocking the potential of soymilk industry waste (Okara): A comprehensive review on valorization and food applications
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53550/jfl.v38.i2.259Keywords:
Soybean, Soymilk Residue, Okara, ValorizationAbstract
Okara, the residue generated during soymilk and tofu production, is a nutrient-dense byproduct often underutilized in industrial and domestic settings. Its composition includes approximately 50–60% moisture, 20–30% dietary fiber, 15–25% protein, 10–12% lipids and various bioactive compounds like isoflavones. Okara offers significant nutritional benefits, including antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and cholesterol-lowering properties. However, its utilization is limited due to high moisture content, perishability, and coarse texture. Various methods are being developed to improve okara’s functional and sensory properties. Drying techniques, including freezedrying, vacuum drying, and spray drying, enhance its shelf life and usability. This review delves into the valorization of okara, emphasizing its potential in sustainable food applications. Okara’s incorporation into bakery products, gluten-free items, dairy alternatives, and functional foods highlights its versatility and economic value. By addressing these challenges, okara can be transformed into an eco-friendly, cost-effective ingredient, aligning with global sustainability goals and reducing food waste. Future research directions aim to optimize processing methods, expand applications, and foster consumer acceptance, positioning Okara as a valuable contributor to the circular economy.
References
Agu H, Ihionu J and Mba J. 2023. Sensory and physicochemical properties of biscuit produced from blends of whole wheat, soy okara, and tigernut residue flours. Heliyon 9 (e15318): 1-13.
Ahmed H, Hawa A, Satheesh N and Dibaba Tolera K. 2018. Functional, physical and sensory properties of cookies prepared from okara, red teff and wheat flours. Croatian Journal of Food Science and Technology 10(1): 23-32.
Ahlawat D, Poonia D, Ahlawat M and Ahlawat SS. 2018. Effect of drying techniques on functional and physicochemical properties of okara. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences 7(5): 582- 590.
Ahlawat D and Punia D. 2012. Effect of solar tunnel and freeze drying techniques on the organoleptic acceptability of products prepared incorporating okara (soy by-product). International Journal of Food and Sciences 3(3): 10-13.
Ambawat S and Khetarpaul N. 2018. Comparative assessment of antioxidant, nutritional and functional properties of soybean and its by-product okara. Annals of Phytomedicine 7(1): 112-118.
Asghar A, Afzaal M, Saeed F, Ahmed A, Ateeq H, Shah YA, Islam F, Hussain M, Akram N and Shah MA. 2023. Valorization and food applications of okara (soybean residue): A concurrent review. Food Science and Nutrition 11(7): 3631-3640.
Asghar A, Afzaal M, Nosheen F, Saeed F, Nayik GA, ALFarga A, Alansari WS, Eskandrani AA and Shamlan G. 2022. Isolation and molecular characterization of processed soybean waste for the development of synbiotic yogurt. Fermentation 8(11): 622.
Aussanasuwannakul A, Teangpook C, Treesuwan W, Puntaburt K and Butsuwan P. 2022. Effect of the addition of soybean residue (okara) on the physicochemical, tribological, instrumental, and sensory texture properties of extruded snacks. Foods 11(19): 2967.
Aussanasuwannakul A, Boonbumrung S and Pantoa T. 2023. Valorization of soybean residue (okara) by supercritical carbon dioxide extraction: Compositional, physicochemical, and functional properties of oil and defatted powder. Foods 12(14): 2698.
Aussanasuwannakul A, Puntaburt K and Pantoa T. 2024. Enhancing gluten-free crispy waffles with soybean residue (okara) flour: Rheological, nutritional, and sensory impacts. Foods 13: 2951.
Azanza MPV and Gascon FS. 2015. Shelf-stable dried okara from the wet by-product of Philippine soybean curd processing. Philippine Journal of Science 144: 171-185.
Bowles S and Demiate IM. 2006. Physicochemical characterization of the soymilk by-product—okara. Food Science and Technology 26: 652-659.
Cao Z, Zhou L, Gao S, Yang C, Meng X and Liu Z. 2024. Effects of different amounts of okara on texture, digestive properties, and microstructure of noodles. Food Science and Nutrition 12(5): 3433-3442.
Colletti A, Attrovio A, Boffa L, Mantegna S and Cravotto G. 2020. Valorisation of by-products from soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) processing. Molecules 25(9):2129.
El-Reffaei W, Ragheb E, El-Ghandour H and Badr S. 2012. Nutritional and technological studies on using okara as by-product for fortified common foods falafel and biscuit. Journal of Food and Dairy Sciences 3(9): 481-506.
Fadhila PT, Rakhmadevi AG, Mardiyanto M and Nurwahyuningsih. 2024. Nutritional value and fiber content of cookies prepared from okara flour substitution: Study on dietary fiber, isoflavone, and chemical properties. 6th International Conference on Food and Agriculture (ICoFA). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1338(012036): 1-7.
Farooq R, Fedrick S, Saeed F, Ahmad A, Asghar A, Riaz S, Ateeq H, Shah Y, Khan M, Li Y and Afzaal M. 2023. Characterization and valorization of soybean residue (okara) for the development of synbiotic ice cream. Food Science and Nutrition 11(e3606): 1-11.
Feng JY, Wang R, Thakur K, Ni ZJ, Zhu YY, Hu F, Zhang JG and Wei ZJ. 2021. Evolution of okara from waste to value-added food ingredient: An account of its biovalorization for improved nutritional and functional effects. Trends in Food Science and Technology 116:669-680.
Gatade AA, Ranveer RC and Sahoo AK. 2014. Effect of treatments, CMC, and storage conditions on sensorial quality of mango flavoured soymilk. Journal of Microbiology, Biotechnology and Food Science 4(1): 6-9.
Gatade A, Ranveer R and Sahoo A. 2009. Physico-chemical and sensorial characteristics of chocolate prepared from soymilk. Advance Journal of Food Science and Technology 1: 1-5.
Genta HD, Genta ML, Alvarez NV and Santana MS. 2002. Production and acceptance of a soy candy. Journal of Food Engineering 53(2): 199-202.
Grizotto RK and Aguirre JMD. 2011. Study of the flash drying of the residue from soymilk processing - “okara”. Food Science and Technology International 31: 645-653.
Grizotto RK, Rufi CRG, Yamada EA and Vicente E. 2010. Evaluation of the quality of a molded sweet biscuit enriched with okara flour. Food Science and Technology 30: 270-275.
Grizotto RK, Andrade JCD, Miyagusku L and Yamada EA. 2012. Physical, chemical, technological and sensory characteristics of Frankfurter type sausage containing okara flour. Food Science and Technology 32: 538-546.
Guimaraes RM, Silva TE, Lemes AC, Boldrin MCF, da Silva MAP, Silva FG and Egea MB. 2018. Okara: A soybean by-product as an alternative to enrich vegetable paste. LWT - Food Science and Technology 92: 593–599.
Guimarães RM, Ida EI, Falcão HG, De Rezende TAM, Silva JDS, Alves CCF, da Silva MA P and Egea MB. 2020. Evaluating technological quality of okara flours obtained by different drying processes LWT-Food Science and Technology 123. 109062.
HawaA, Satheesh N and Kumela D. 2018. Nutritional and anti-nutritional evaluation of cookies prepared from okara, red teff, and wheat flours. International Food Research Journal 25(5): 2042-2050.
Huq S, Das PC, Islam MA, Jubayer MF, Ranganathan TV and Mazumder MAR. 2021. Nutritional, textural, and sensory quality of oil fried donut enriched with extracted dietary fiber and okara flour. Journal of Food Processing and Preservation 45(3): 1-14.
Hongsprabhas P and Hongsprabhas P. 2012. Controlling of viscosity and gelation in pasteurised high-calorie oil-in-water emulsion: use of okara as dietary fiber. Proceedings of the Polymer Processing Society 28th Annual Meeting PPS- 28: 1-5
Jimenez-Escrig A, Tenorio MD, Espinosa-Martos I and Rupérez P. 2008. Health-promoting effects of a dietary fiber concentrate from the soybean byproduct okara in rats. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 56:7495–7501.
Kang MJ, Bae IY and Lee HG. 2018. Rice noodle enriched with okara: Cooking property, texture, and in vitro starch digestibility. Food Bioscience 22: 178-183.
Kamble DB, Singh R, Rani S and Pratap D. 2019. Physicochemical properties, in vitro digestibility and structural attributes of okara enriched functional pasta. Journal of Food Process and Preservation 43(e14232): 1-9.
Kamble D and Rani S. 2020. Bioactive components, in vitro digestibility, microstructure and application of soybean residue (okara): A review. Legume Science 2(1): e32.
Kele V, Kele A., Chudasama M and Goyary J. 2023. A review: Preparation of products from seed-based okara and corn (Zea mays). TechnischeSicherheit 23: 231-245.
Khare SK, Jha K and Sinha LK. 1995. Preparation and nutritional evaluation of okara fortified biscuits. Journal of Dairying, Foods and Home Science 14: 91-94.
Kuligowski M, Radziejewska-Kubzdela E, Górna O, Jasińska-Kuligowska I and Kidoń M 2024. Sustainable use of by-products (okara and linseed cake) in tempeh fermentation: Effects on isoflavones and lignans. Sustainability 16(22): 9936.
Li B, Qiao M and Lu F. 2012. Composition, nutrition, and utilization of okara (soybean residue). Food Reviews International 28(3): 231-252.
Li B, Yang W, Nie Y, Kang F, Goff HD and Cui SW. 2019. Effect of steam explosion on dietary fiber, polysaccharide, protein and physicochemical properties of okara. Food Hydrocolloids 94: 48-56.
Li J and Hsieh YHP. 2004. Traditional Chinese food technology and cuisine. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 13:147-155.
Li Y, Song H, Zhang Z, Li R, Zhang Y, Yang L, Li J, Zhu D, Liu J, Yu H and Liu H. 2024. Effects of fermentation with different probiotics on the quality, isoflavone content, and flavor of okara beverages. Food Science and Nutrition 12(4): 2619-2633.
Lu F, Liu Y and Li B. 2013. Okara dietary fiber and hypoglycemic effect of okara foods. Bioactive Carbohydrates and Dietary Fibre 2(2): 126-132.
Lu F, Cui Z, Liu Y and Li B. 2013. The effect of okara on the qualities of noodle and steamed bread. Advance Journal of Food Science and Technology 5: 960-968.
Mahfudz MK, Jaikhan S, Phirom-on K and Apiraksakorn J. 2024. Cost-effective strategy and feasibility for amylase production from okara by Bacillus subtilis J12. Fermentation 10(11): 561.
Maria MF and Olaitan AE.2020. Effect of supplementing cassava with okara on biscuit quality. Sumerianz Journal of Biotechnology 3: 99-105.
Mbaeyi-Nwaoha IE and Uchendu NO. 2016. Production and evaluation of breakfast cereals from blends of acha and fermented soybean paste (okara). Journal of Food Science and Technology 53(1): 50–70.
Mansor A, Mahadi SK and Othaman MA. 2022. Okara yoghurt–a high value-added fermented product from soybean curd residue. Food Research 6: 97-106.
Moraes Filho ML, Busanello M and Garcia S. 2016. Optimization of the fermentation parameters for the growth of Lactobacillus in soymilk with okara flour. LWT-Food Science and Technology 74: 456-464.
Nagata Y, Yamasaki S, Torisu N, Suzuki T, Shimamoto S, Tamaru S and Tanaka K. 2016. Okara, a by-product of tofu manufacturing, modifies triglyceride metabolism at the intestinal and hepatic levels. Journal of Nutritional Science and Vitaminology 62(3): 162-169.
Nasution Z, Tung M Y and Faridah Y. 2012. Okara: An alternative ingredient for partial substitution of peanuts in peanut butter. Peanut Science 13(1): 18-20.
Noriham A, Muhammad Ariffaizuddin R, Noorlaila A and Faris Zakry AN. 2016. Potential use of okara as meat replacer in beef sausage. Journal Teknologi 78(6):13-18.
Osthoff G, Hugo A, Van Wyk P, De Wit M and Meyer S. 2010. Characterization of a spray-dried soymilk powder and changes observed during storage. Food Science and Technology International 16(2): 169-178.
OstermannPorcel V, Rinaldoni A, Rodriguez Furlán L and Campderros M. 2016. Quality assessment of dried okara as a source of production of gluten-free flour. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 97: 2675-3080.
O’Toole DK. 1999. Characteristics and use of okara, the soybean residue from soy milk production - a review. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 47(2): 363-371.
O’Toole DK. 2004. Soybean. In Soymilk and OC Wrigley (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Grain Science. Cambridge: Elsevier Ltd.: 185–195.
Pan WC, Liu YM and Shiau SY. 2018. Effect of okara and vital gluten on physico-chemical properties of noodle. Czech Journal of Food Science 36: 301–306.
Privatti RT and Rodrigues CE.da C. 2021. An overview of the composition, applications, and recovery techniques of the components of okara aimed at the biovalorization of this soybean processing residue. Food Reviews International 39(2): 726-749.
Paul AA, Kumar S, Kumar V and Sharma R. 2020. Milk Analog. Plant-based alternatives to conventional milk, production, potential and health concerns. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 60(18): 3005-3023.
Paramita VS and Budi AP. 2015. Utilization of dried okara as a flour mixture for bread-making. Journal of Business on Hospitality and Tourism 1(6): 1-10.
Pešić MB, Pešić MM, Bezbradica J, Stanojević AB, Ivković P, Milinčić DD, Demin M, Kostić AŽ, Dojčinović B and Stanojević SP. 2023. Okara-enriched gluten-free bread: Nutritional, antioxidant, and sensory properties. Molecules 28(10): 4098.
Préstamo G, Rupérez P, Espinosa-Martos I, Villanueva MJ and Lasunción MA. 2007. The effects of okara on rat growth, faecal fermentation, and serum lipids. European Food Research and Technology 225(5): 925–928.
Pérez-López E, Veses AM, Redondo N, Tenorio-Sanz MD, Villanueva MJ, Redondo-Cuenca A and Rupérez P. 2018. Soybean okara modulates gut microbiota in rats fed a high-fat diet. Bioactive Carbohydrates and Dietary Fibre 16: 100-107.
Perussello CA, Mariani VC and Do Amarante ÁCC. 2014. Thermophysical properties of okara during drying. International Journal of Food Properties 17(4): 891-907
Perussello CA, Mariani VC and Do Amarante ÁCC. 2012. Numerical and experimental analysis of the heat and mass transfer during okara drying. Applied Thermal Engineering 48: 325-331.
Perussello CA, Do Amarante ÁCC and Mariani VC. 2009. Convective drying kinetics and darkening of okara. Drying Technology 27(10): 1132-1141.
Quintana G, Gerbino E and Gómez-Zavaglia A. 2017. Okara: A nutritionally valuable by-product able to stabilize Lactobacillus plantarum during freeze-drying, spray-drying, and storage. Frontiers in Microbiology8: 641.
Queiroz Santos VA, Nascimento CG, Schmidt CAP, Mantovani D, Dekker RFH and da Cunha MAA. 2018. Solid-state fermentation of soybean okara: Isoflavones biotransformation, antioxidant activity, and enhancement of nutritional quality. LWT-Food Science and Technology 92: 509-515.
Radočaj O and Dimić E. 2013. Valorization of Wet Okara, a Value-Added Functional Ingredient, in a Coconut- Based Baked Snack. Cereal Chemistry 90: 256-262.
Razavizadeh S, Alencikiene G, Salaseviciene A, Vaičiulytė-Funk L, Ertbjerg P and Zabulionė A. 2021. Impact of fermentation of okara on physicochemical, techno-functional, and sensory properties of meat analogues. European Food Research and Technology247: 1801–1811.
Roslan IND, Kamaruding NA, Ismail N and Shaharuddin S. 2021. Sensory attributes and other properties of yogurt fortified with immobilized Lactobacillus plantarum and soybean residue (okara). International Journal of Probiotics and Prebiotics 16: 1–6.
Saini A and Morya S. 2021. A review-based study on soymilk: Focuses on production technology, prospects, and progress scenario in the last decade. The Pharma Innovation 10(5): 486-494.
Santos DCD, Oliveira Filho JGD, Silva JDS, Sousa MFD, Vilela MDS, Silva MAPD and Egea MB. 2019. Okara flour: Its physicochemical, microscopical, and functional properties. Nutrition and Food Science 49(6): 1252-1264.
Sari AM and Syamsudin AB. 2019. Effect of tofu waste flour composition to hedonic test level and proximate test of bread. In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 674(1): 1-5.
SenguptaS, Chakraborty M, Bhowal J and Bhattacharya DK. 2012. Study on the effects of drying process on the composition and quality of wet okara. International Journal of Science, Environment and Technology 1(4): 319-330.
Swallah MS, Fan H, Wang S, Yu H and Piao C. 2021. Prebiotic impacts of soybean residue (okara) on eubiosis/dysbiosis condition of the gut and the possible effects on liver and kidney functions. Molecules 26(2): 326.
Szulc J, Błaszak B, Wenda-Piesik A, Gozdecka G, Żary- Sikorska E, Bąk M and Bauza-Kaszewska J. 2023. Zero waste technology of soybeans processing. Sustainability 15(20): 14873.
Turhan S, Temiz H and Sagir I. 2009. Characteristics of beef patties using okara powder. Journal of Muscle Foods 20(1): 89-100.
Tridtitanakiat PC, Hernández-Estrada ZJ and Rayas- Duarte P. 2023. Modeling the influence of okara flour supplementation from time-temperature drying treatment on the quality of gluten-free roll produced from rice flour. Foods 12: 3421.
Varsha K and Mohan S. 2016. Production of value-added snacks from rice broken and okara by extrusion cooking technology. International Journal of Agricultural Sciences 8(51): 2321-2325.
Vishwanathan KH, Govindaraju K, Singh V and Subramanian R. 2011. Production of okara and soy protein concentrates using membrane technology. Journal of Food Science 76(1): E158–E164.
Vong WC and Liu SQ. 2016. Biovalorisation of okara (soybean residue) for food and nutrition. Trends in Food Science and Technology 52: 139-147.
Vong WC, Lim XY and Liu SQ. 2017. Biotransformation with cellulase, hemicellulase, and Yarrowialipolytica boosts health benefits of okara. Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 101: 7129-7140.
Voss GB, Vera S, Paulo R, Manuela EP and Luísa MPV. 2021. Okara (by-product of soya beverage): Potential application in food and aquafeed. Animals 11(590):1-17.
Walgiyanti I, Mahardika A and Murti PDB. 2024. The substitution of different concentrations of okara flour in brownies formulation added with flaxseed (Linum usitatissimum) as low-gluten healthy food. Journal of Functional Food and Nutraceutical 5(1): 79-86.
Xia T, Cai Y, Liu T, Long Z, Huang L, Deng X, Zhao Q and Zhao M. 2019. Effects of pretreatments on the structure and functional properties of okara protein. Food Hydrocolloids 90: 394-402.
Xie L, Zhou W, Zhao L, Peng J, Zhou X, Qian X and Lu L. 2023. Impact of okara on quality and in vitro starch digestibility of noodles: The view based on physicochemical and structural properties. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules 237(1): 124105.
Yaseen A, Shouk A and Abousalem F. 2009. Effect of okara addition on bread quality. Journal of Food and Dairy Sciences 34(12): 11147-11155.
Zhong Y and Zhao Y. 2015. Chemical composition and functional properties of three soy processing byproducts (soy hull, okara and molasses). Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops and Foods 1: 1-10.
